Friday, November 20, 2026
HomeBusinessEU Stands Firm on €120M Fine Against X Amid U.S. Support for...

EU Stands Firm on €120M Fine Against X Amid U.S. Support for Musk

On Friday, the European Union’s executive body announced its readiness to uphold a €120 million ($137 million US) penalty against the social media platform X, following support from the U.S. government for Elon Musk’s legal challenge to dismiss the case.

Last year, the European Commission imposed the fine on X for violations of the EU’s significant digital regulations, escalating tensions with the United States. This fine is equivalent to approximately $194 million Cdn.

This action by the EU came after a two-year investigation and marked the first enforcement of the bloc’s digital regulations concerning online content. Regulators asserted that X’s blue checkmarks violated regulations due to “deceptive design practices,” which could potentially lead users to scams and manipulation.

On Thursday, the U.S. Justice Department revealed it had filed documents supporting X’s request to have the case dismissed by the European Union’s General Court.

Brett Shumate, assistant attorney general for the Justice Department’s Civil Division, stated, “We will not accept the European Commission’s regulatory overreach aimed at controlling American engines of innovation and economic growth.”

Thomas Regnier, spokesperson for the European Commission, emphasized the EU’s “sovereign right” to create laws that protect its citizens.

He told reporters, “We are enforcing our legislation in an objective and transparent manner, backed by a robust case. We are prepared to defend our stance in court. We possess substantial evidence, and it will ultimately be up to the court to make a decision, as is customary.”

WATCH | Trump lashes out at possible Canada-EU alliance:

Trump threatens new tariffs over Canada-EU alliance if it’s ‘a hostile act’

September 16|

Duration

2:32

U.S. President Donald Trump lashed out at a possible Canada-EU trade alliance, threatening new tariffs if he finds it to be ‘a hostile act.’ Meanwhile, Democrats in Washington expressed sympathy for Canada and said trade talks should resume.

The commission serves as the principal enforcer of the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA), which mandates that technology firms improve their online platforms or face substantial fines.

The DSA sets forth strict obligations to ensure the safety of internet users, including simplifying the process for reporting counterfeit or unsafe products and flagging harmful or illegal content like hate speech, along with a prohibition on ads directed at children.

However, this regulatory framework has become a contentious issue with the Trump administration, which has criticized it as a form of online censorship.

When asked if the Justice Department had notified the commission of its intention to support Musk, Regnier replied, “We do not require any notification on this matter.”

He indicated that the commission does not anticipate this case to adversely affect the wider relationship between Brussels and Washington, especially regarding discussions aimed at alleviating the impact of tariffs from the Trump administration.

“From our viewpoint, this DSA case will not lead to any changes,” he stated.

‘In conflict with U.S. law’

The Justice Department cautioned that if the fine is upheld, it “could have significant repercussions” for U.S. online platforms and other firms providing digital services within the EU.

Shumate stated in Thursday’s announcement that the “European Commission has improperly sought to extend its regulatory jurisdiction to American companies that are neither present nor operating within its authority.”

Ankush Khardori, a former U.S. federal prosecutor, stated on his website on Friday that Shumate’s assertion constituted “a fundamental misunderstanding that contradicts U.S. law.”

He explained, “A company does not need to have a physical presence in a location to operate within that jurisdiction and be subject to its laws.”

Khardori also remarked that it was “ironic” for the Justice Department to urge the EU to “adhere to the generally accepted understanding of territorial jurisdiction in international law,” given that the Trump administration has faced accusations of actions contrary to international law, such as their seizure of Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro and their deadly strikes on vessels allegedly involved in drug trafficking.

On Thursday evening, Musk was present among tech leaders at a state dinner hosted by Trump in honor of China’s leader Xi Jinping.

Musk contributing to Republican candidates again

This marks the second instance in three months where the Justice Department has stepped in to advocate for a company owned by Musk.

In July, the department submitted a motion to intervene in a civil rights lawsuit claiming that Musk’s xAI is unlawfully operating numerous natural gas turbines to supply power for a $20 billion US AI data center in Mississippi. The plaintiffs in this case argued that xAI did not obtain the necessary permit for its power facility, which is situated near residential areas, schools, and places of worship.

SpaceX’s stratospheric IPO makes Elon Musk world’s first trillionaire

June 12|

Duration

2:03

SpaceX is now a publicly traded company worth over $2 trillion US after a stratospheric Nasdaq debut on Friday that made founder Elon Musk the first trillionaire, with a new estimated net worth of $1.1 trillion US.

The previous tensions between Trump and Musk, which had shocked both Washington and Wall Street last year after Musk labeled Trump’s tax cuts and spending reductions a “disgusting abomination,” seemed to have eased.

These comments followed Musk’s controversial appointment as a special government employee, where he led a cost-reduction initiative within the federal government. He was assigned these duties despite existing concerns over conflicts of interest, as his companies frequently pursued government contracts or had been involved in civil lawsuits against federal agencies.

Musk’s role with the Department of Governmental Efficiency, which concluded in May 2025, could be scrutinized if Democrats reclaim one or both houses of Congress in the upcoming midterm elections on November 3. Some Democratic legislators are calling for Musk to be subpoenaed to provide testimony regarding his actions at DOGE.

Once again, Musk is utilizing his super PAC to financially support Republican candidates in the lead-up to the midterm elections.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular